Posts filed under ‘Solaris’

Solaris as an Open Source alternative to Linux

When I left Solaris after the Sun/Oracle marger, it was because I wanted to try some new things in life possibly based on OpenSolaris. I had led Solaris in networking and network virtualization space for a long time and wanted to make a bigger mark in that space compared to what Oracle might have wanted. But my hope was that Solaris as a Open Source Operating System would continue to prosper and I could possibly use OpenSolaris as a base for whatever I decided to do next. Well, the exodus from Solaris has continued over the past few months and now Mike has also decided to call it quits. Mike was one of my counterparts, running the storage side of the house (other leaders in storage and filesystem space, like Jeff and Bryan had already bailed out of Solaris few months after I left).

So at this point, I am forced to consider the fact that Solaris and OpenSolaris are on the brink of death unless something serious is done about it. Having spent so much time and energy in last 15 years on Solaris (including bringing it back from life after the last tech bust when Solaris had been labeled Slowlaris), I would personally like to see it go on. Given the richness of Solaris and what it offers to developers, the opensource community doesn’t deserve to lose it. We had relentlessly added APIs for all the networking and virtualization code (Crossbow and Zones) in past few years to name a few. Dealing with creating VNICs, walking links, creating Zones, etc from a developer point of view is very easy (more on what’s there for developers some other day).

So the question I have been pondering for last few weeks is what does it take to create a truly vibrant OpenSource kernel as an alternative to Linux. During Sun days, we had tried to set up Solaris as an open source alternative to Linux and we moved all development, process, architectural review, etc in the open but somehow the community never truly believed us. But now with Oracle having closed source the OS and struggling to keep it alive, there might be truly an opportunity for OpenSolaris to be reborn as an true opensource alternative to Linux. There seems to some effort already in form of illumos led by Garrett and an OpenIndiana distro. Now Garrett works for Nexenta who has a business based on Solaris I do believe they can throw some resources to keep it running.

What does an open source OS need?

There are several things that are needed on short term that doesn’t take too many resources. Not in any particular order of importance:

  • Drivers for new device
    I have seen Garrett personally dish out drivers faster then people can install and test them so he can at least keep one part of the OS
    alive i.e. drivers for new devices.
  • Packaging, Delivery and Install
    Then there is the packaging, delivery etc. which someone has to pick up. Perhaps the OpenIndiana guys can make that their core competency. Maybe they can finish the IPS system and make changes for the file based URI that it had already started to go towards. Things like: 

    • Allow someone to make a non network clone of the repo (at least for the true opensource packages including the kernel). This allows enough people to feel that they truly have control over all aspects on the kernel without need a repo server that they don’t control. Maybe something as simple as installing a server from the network repo along the lines of
      % pkg image-create file:///var/pkg file:///my_repo
      % pkg image-create -g origin_server file:///my_repo
    • Allowing someone to save a copy of a package locally that he can later install. Something like this
      % pkg clone [-g origin_server] pkg_fmri_pattern /local_path
    • And allow some to install the saved package over riding the dependency check if needed.
      % pkg install [-f] file:///net/hostname/local_path
      % pkg install [-f] [-g origin_server] pkg_fmri_pattern

    Of course, the directions above are just some thoughts – the details of which need to be refined based on input from the end users. The hosting etc necessary for repo servers for delivery is perhaps the easy part. The install is another story altogether, given that a large amount of code for automatic install has not even been opensourced but I think we can go by for a few years before that has to be addressed.

  • Bug fixing
    Again, given the Solaris talent now outside of Oracle, this is easy. For Bryan, who works at Joyent which again depends on Solaris, doing some P1 fixes is easy. I can do some critical fixes when necessary and there are so many others now outside of Oracle that we need to reach out to
  • New Platform Support
    As new chips come out, you need to add support at the minimum. Now we are getting into some tricky business. I have been discussing the idea of an OpenSolaris Foundation with some companies that support such open source initiatives. I have discussed that with some of the ex Sun DEs and Sr. Engineers as well and it seems appealing to people. Two things needed to happen for this to take off. One was Oracle having truly killed OpenSolaris so there is a clean fork (which I think has already happened). The other is a harder problem and which is the last thing on my list.
  • Mission and Innovation
    The open source OS for the sake of another OS is not very palatable to people who can fund the foundation. I got suggestions around mobile
    space for which I don’t think Solaris is ideal OS (yet). There seem to be interest along the direction of moving Solaris as a distributed OS in the cloud space. This gels with what I have been working on along with few others – a distributed network operating system geared
    towards clouds. Maybe moving my effort on top of Solaris would provide the mission in one direction (and my own requirement to use Solaris
    has been now met i.e. Oracle should kill it so there is no ambiguity). There is a revolution happening in that space already with Openflow, Trill,
    etc. and I am trying to figure out how to break the last barrier in the datacenter.

So to answer the question What have I been upto? –  now you know. And to answer the question Will I allow my work on Solaris to die?  I guess the answer is resounding- No. Will I port things like Crossbow and Zones to freebsd? – the answer is if OpenSolaris truly dies, then hell yes. And before someone points out that Zones is really same as BSD Jails, you should look again carefully.

So Solaris users and Solaris lovers, love to hear your thoughts.


October 23, 2010 at 9:23 am 15 comments

Top Rated

Recent Posts

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 177 other followers